Category Archives: Tobacco (HRS 245)

HB 441

SUBJECT: TOBACCO, Hawaiʻi Cancer Research Special Fund

BILL NUMBER: HB 441

INTRODUCED BY: GARRETT, CHUN, Evslin, Kapela, Keohokapu-Lee Loy, Kila, La Chica, Marten, Olds, Sayama

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Beginning 7/1/2025, increases the cigarette tax and amends the cigarette tax disposition of revenues by allocating the increase in the cigarette tax amount to the Hawaiʻi Cancer Research Special Fund. Continue reading HB 441 →

HB 2504 HD 2 SD 1

SUBJECT: CIGARETTE, TOBACCO, Tax Hike, Increase Earmark to Cancer Research Special Fund

BILL NUMBER: HB 2504 HD 2 SD 1

INTRODUCED BY: Senate Committees on Health and Human Services and Higher Education

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Beginning July 1, 2024, expands the cigarette tax levied upon a wholesaler or dealer under section 245-3, HRS, to electronic smoking devices and e-liquids. Requires 1.0 cents per cigarette, electronic smoking device, and e-liquid, but not more than $500,000 per fiscal year, to be deposited into the credit of the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund. Repeals research expenses as an authorized use of funds in the Hawaiʻi Cancer Research Special Fund. Prohibits the Cancer Center of Hawaiʻi’s Early Clinical Trial Program from receiving moneys from the Hawaiʻi Cancer Research Special Fund. Continue reading HB 2504 HD 2 SD 1 →

HB 2504 HD 2

SUBJECT: CIGARETTE, TOBACCO, Tax Hike, Increase Earmark to Cancer Research Special Fund

BILL NUMBER: HB 2504 HD 2

INTRODUCED BY: House Committee on Finance

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Establishes a cigarette floor inventory tax on the stock inventory of cigarettes held by licensees before any increase in cigarette and tobacco tax laws is to be assessed and levied. Amends the cigarette tax rate and specifies the disposition of revenues collected at the amended rate. Continue reading HB 2504 HD 2 →

HB 2341 HD 2

SUBJECT: TOBACCO; Cigarette Tax Stamp Fees; Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund; Hawaiʻi Tobacco Settlement Special Fund

BILL NUMBER:  HB 2341 HD 2

INTRODUCED BY: House Committee on Finance

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Establishes a stamp fee floor inventory tax on the stock inventory of stamps held by licensees before any increase in the stamp fee under the cigarette and tobacco tax laws is assessed and levied. Amends the ceiling for the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund. Amends the cigarette tax stamp fee and the percentage of the cigarette tax stamp fee deposited to the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund. Amends the amount to be deposited to the credit of the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund from tobacco settlement moneys. Continue reading HB 2341 HD 2 →

SB 3335 SD 2

SUBJECT:  ADMINISTRATION, INCOME, GENERAL EXCISE, TOBACCO, MISCELLANEOUS, Legalize and Tax Adult-Use Cannabis

BILL NUMBER: SB 3335 SD 2

INTRODUCED BY: Senate Committees on Commerce and Consumer Protection and Ways and Means

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Establishes the Hawaiʻi Hemp and Cannabis Authority and Hemp and Cannabis Control Board within the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs to regulate all aspects of the cannabis plant. Establishes the Hemp and Cannabis Control Implementation Advisory Committee. Beginning January 1, 2026, legalizes the personal adult use of cannabis. Establishes taxes for adult-use cannabis and medical cannabis sales. Transfers the personnel and assets of the Department of Health and assets of the Department of Agriculture to the Hawaiʻi Hemp and Cannabis Authority. Continue reading SB 3335 SD 2 →

SB 3335 SD 1

SUBJECT:  INCOME, GENERAL EXCISE, TOBACCO, MISCELLANEOUS, Legalize and Tax Adult-Use Cannabis

BILL NUMBER: SB 3335 SD 1

INTRODUCED BY: Senate Committees on Health and Human Services and Judiciary

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Establishes the Hawaiʻi Cannabis Authority and Cannabis Control Board within the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs to regulate all aspects of the cannabis plant. Establishes the Cannabis Control Implementation Advisory Committee. Beginning January 1, 2026, legalizes the personal adult use of cannabis. Establishes taxes for adult-use cannabis and medical cannabis sales. Transfers the personnel and assets of the Department of Health and assets of the Department of Agriculture to the Hawaiʻi Cannabis Authority. Continue reading SB 3335 SD 1 →

HB 2504 HD 1

SUBJECT: CIGARETTE, TOBACCO, Tax Hike, Increase Earmark to Cancer Research Special Fund

BILL NUMBER: HB 2504 HD 1

INTRODUCED BY: House Committees on Higher Education & Technology and Health & Homelessness

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Increases the cigarette tax and amends the cigarette tax disposition of revenues by allocating the increase in the cigarette tax amount to the Hawaiʻi cancer research special fund. Continue reading HB 2504 HD 1 →

HB 2341 HD 1

SUBJECT: TOBACCO; Cigarette Tax Stamp Fees; Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund; Hawaiʻi Tobacco Settlement Special Fund

BILL NUMBER:  HB 2341 HD 1

INTRODUCED BY: House Committee on Health & Homelessness

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Amends the amount of funding for the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund administered by the Department of the Attorney General by amending the amount of funds that the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund can carry over at the end of the fiscal year; increasing the cigarette tax stamp fee and concurrently increasing the percentage of the cigarette tax stamp fee deposited to the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund; and amending the amount of funds to be deposited to the credit of the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund from tobacco settlement moneys.

SYNOPSIS:  Amends section 28-15, HRS, to allow the tobacco enforcement special fund to accumulate funds up to $750,000 (up from $500,000) without the excess lapsing to the general fund.

Amends section 245-26, HRS, to increase the stamp fee from 1.7% to 2.2% of the value of tax stamps sold, and to route the additional 0.5% to the tobacco enforcement special fund.

Amends section 328L-2, HRS, to increase the earmark on tobacco settlement moneys to the tobacco enforcement special fund from $350,000 to $750,000 per fiscal year.

EFFECTIVE DATE: July 1, 3000.

STAFF COMMENTS:  This is an Administration bill sponsored by the Department of Attorney General and designated ATG-02 (24).

The question that should be asked is what the purpose of the tobacco tax is. If the goal is to make people stop smoking by making it cost-prohibitive to smoke, then (a) it’s working, as hikes in the cigarette tax have begun to exert downward pressure on collections not only locally but also nationally, but (b) it shouldn’t be expected to raise revenue, because of (a). If the goal is really to stop the behavior, why are we not banning it?

As the Foundation’s previous President, Lowell Kalapa, wrote in the Tax Foundation of Hawaii’s weekly commentary on October 28, 2012:

Lawmakers seem to have a simplistic reaction to solving problems the solution to which plagues their constituents – tax it.

Probably the best example is what people like to call sin taxes, those excise taxes that are levied on tobacco and alcohol products.  After all, smoking causes cancer and alcohol causes all sorts of problems including driving under the influence.  Lawmakers and community advocates shake their heads and push for higher tax rates, arguing that making these products more expensive will deter folks from using these products.

The problem is that lawmakers also like the revenues that are generated from the sales of these products and, in some cases, they have tried to link the use and sale of these products with noble causes such as the funding of the Cancer Research Center that is currently being built.  Again, the argument is that smokers should pay for programs and projects which seek to cure the related ill which in this case is cancer caused by smoking.

The irony is that arguments to increase the tax on tobacco and, more specifically, cigarettes, is a goal of getting smokers to quit while depending on the revenues from tobacco and cigarette taxes to fund an ongoing program, in this case the Cancer Research Center.  So, which is it folks, stop smokers from smoking and if successful, there won’t be any revenues to fund the Cancer Research Center?

The fact of the matter is that it appears that both locally and nationally, higher taxes on cigarettes are influencing smokers as tax collections on the sale of cigarettes have fallen.  Certainly, some of the decline is due to smokers actually quitting, but to some degree one has to suspect that some purchases were made via mail order from exempt Indian reservation outlets while others may be what is called gray market purchases, that is from sources outside the country.

What should come as a surprise is that most of the folks who have quit are of some means as they are more likely to recognize the health hazard caused by use of this product. That means most of those who are still smoking are among the lower-income members of our community.  Thus, the tax is regressive, generating less and less collections from middle and higher-income individuals.

Kalapa, “Finding the Blame for What Ails You,” at https://www.tfhawaii.org/wordpress/blog/­2012/10/finding-the-blame-for-what-ails-you/  (Oct, 28, 2012).

As predicted, programs that have been fed by earmarks from the tobacco tax, like the Cancer Research Center, have become a victim of the success of tobacco cessation programs and publicity.  Revenues produced by the tobacco tax have been in steady decline over the past few years despite tax rate increases and hoisting the smoking age to 21 in the 2015 session certainly didn’t reverse the trend.

Source:  Department of Taxation Annual Report (2022-2023), page 24.

Fiscal reliance on funds from a sin tax is inadvisable, perhaps outright dangerous.  If the goal is to affect social behavior, use of the tax law is not the most effective way to do so.

Digested:  2/26/2024

HB 2341, SB 3030

SUBJECT: TOBACCO; Cigarette Tax Stamp Fees; Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund; Hawaiʻi Tobacco Settlement Special Fund

BILL NUMBER:  HB 2341, SB 3030

INTRODUCED BY: HB by SAIKI; SB by KOUCHI (Governor’s Package)

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Amends the amount of funding for the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund administered by the Department of the Attorney General by amending the amount of funds that the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund can carry over at the end of the fiscal year; increasing the cigarette tax stamp fee and concurrently increasing the percentage of the cigarette tax stamp fee deposited to the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund; and amending the amount of funds to be deposited to the credit of the Tobacco Enforcement Special Fund from tobacco settlement moneys. Continue reading HB 2341, SB 3030 →

SB 3335, HB 2600

SUBJECT:  INCOME, GENERAL EXCISE, TOBACCO, MISCELLANEOUS, Legalize and Tax Adult-Use Cannabis

BILL NUMBER: SB 3335, HB 2600

INTRODUCED BY: SB by KEOHOKALOLE, AWA, CHANG, DECOITE, FEVELLA, KANUHA, LEE, SAN BUENAVENTURA, Kidani, Kim; HB by TARNAS, AMATO, BELATTI, GANADEN, GATES, HOLT, HUSSEY-BURDICK, KAHALOA, KAPELA, LOWEN, MARTEN, MIYAKE, PERRUSO, POEPOE, TAKAYAMA, TODD, Sayama

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Establishes the Hawaiʻi Cannabis Authority and Cannabis Control Board within the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs to regulate all aspects of the cannabis plant. Beginning January 1, 2026, legalizes the personal adult use of cannabis. Establishes taxes for adult-use cannabis sales. Transfers the personnel and assets of the Department of Health and assets Department of Agriculture to the Hawaiʻi Cannabis Authority. Continue reading SB 3335, HB 2600 →